Reviewing the 2025 Rookies
Posted April 19th, 2026 | No Comments »With the Eagles about to add a new rookie class in a few days, I thought it would be a good time to take a look at last year’s class and how they did. It can offer some good perspective. Everyone is an optimist in April, but reality sets in during the season and potential becomes a bad thing if unfulfilled.
Jihaad Campbell was the first round pick. We were shocked the Eagles went with an off-ball LB that early. It was the first time since 1979. Campbell was forced to start because Nakobe Dean was hurt. Campbell started 10 games, finishing fourth on the team with 80 tackles. He had an INT, a FR, 2 TFLs, 1 FF and 3 PDs. He showed a lot of potential, but did have his ups and downs. He showed cover skills. He was a solid tackler. His run defense was up and down, but that comes with adjusting to the pro game. Overall there was a lot to like.
Jihaad Campbell showing off the range and upside in coverage running the chute in Tampa 2 #Eagles pic.twitter.com/iNeTOUIXIT
— Fran Duffy (@FDuffyNFL) September 6, 2025
Jihaad Campbell played more than 40 snaps for the first time since week 7 and looked AWESOME…
Someone enlighten me as to why he isn’t playing more? pic.twitter.com/vQvMj9JkBD
— NFL Draft Files (@NFL_DF) December 30, 2025
Campbell has a bright future and should be a key player for years to come.
***
Safety Drew Mukuba was the second round pick and another guy who got on the field right away. The Eagles saw his playmaking ability over the summer and wanted him on the field. He started 10 games and had 46 tackles, 2 INTs, 3 PDs, 2 TFLs and half a sack. Mukuba did make plays right away, but also had some costly coverage breakdowns early on. As good as the SEC is, NFL QBs are on a much different level and he found that out the hard way. The good news is that he adjusted and played more consistently as the season went along.
Have a day, Andrew Mukuba. pic.twitter.com/YrYizI1HnK
— Mike Garafolo (@MikeGarafolo) September 14, 2025
Great tackle by Drew Mukuba and then the Eagles stopped the Chiefs on fourth down!
pic.twitter.com/xLzyL0KyZG— John Clark (@JClarkNBCS) September 14, 2025
I believe #Eagles rookie safety Andrew Mukuba had his best coverage game this season against Minnesota watching back the film and the numbers back that up.
Per @NextGenStats Carson Wentz’s QB rating with Mukuba as the nearest defender was 36.7, the lowest among qualified Eagles… pic.twitter.com/vOZX79mZ2V
— Devin Jackson (@RealD_Jackson) October 20, 2025
Some people might have gotten spoiled by Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean. Those guys were great from day one. Mukuba is more of a typical player. He showed talent right away, but it took him time to fully adjust to the NFL. I think he’ll be a good safety for the team for the next several years.
***
Howie moved out of the third round and took DT Ty Robinson in the fourth. Robinson had an underwhelming rookie season. He played in 11 games, had 5 tackles and 1 QB hit. I went back and looked at my draft notes. I loved his motor and athleticism, but noted that he struggled to get off blocks. Most of Robinson’s PT came in the season finale when starters rested. He showed a good motor and athleticism. But he really struggled to get off blocks.
Don’t get too down on him. Many DL struggle with that early on. OL play in college is erratic. The NFL is much tougher and it takes time to adjust. Nick Sirianni loves to talk about block destruction. That’s what Robinson must focus on this offseason. The good news is that Clint Hurtt is a terrific DL coach. Think about Gabe Hall. He looked completely lost as a rookie and then pushed for a roster spot last year. He made a huge leap. Robinson is more talented than Hall. If he can have the same kind of leap that Hall did, Robinson can be a good rotational DL this season. The potential is there.
6) Hey, I thought Ty Robinson made some plays against the run! He’s obviously had a very disappointing rookie season, but he showed some flashes in this game as a run defender. Which is something, at least! pic.twitter.com/qswCGdgLuc
— Jonny Page (@JonnyPage9) January 6, 2026
The Eagles can’t count on that leap. It doesn’t always happen. They could look to add another DT this week. It is worth noting that Howie Roseman said the Eagles were very high on Robinson and were excited to add him. This is a guy they have high hopes for.
***
Mac McWilliams was the first of three fifth round picks. He spent time in the slot and outside over the summer, but never really developed at either spot. Vic Fangio spoke highly of him so this is a player he sees something in. We didn’t see it because McWilliams only played five games in the regular season. He did have a good showing in the preseason.
7) I also think the Eagles might have something with Mac McWilliams (22). He has flashed in preseason. Just look at the click-and-close speed here. I still expect he will end up as the backup nickel, but if Adore Jackson and Kelee Ringo struggle outside, I wouldn’t be opposed to… pic.twitter.com/kBkk6HYV9X
— Jonny Page (@JonnyPage9) August 25, 2025
It will be interesting to see what the Eagles do with him this summer. Do they have him focus outside or in the slot?
***
LB Smael Mondon was next up in the fifth. He played in all 17 games, mainly on STs. He finished the season with 11 tackles. He had a terrible preseason debut, missing tackles and really struggling. We all wondered why they drafted this guy. Over the next two games he had 7 tackles and 2 TFLs. He played with more confidence and his tackling was much, much better.
10) Let’s end with Smael Mondon (42), who really struggled last week but had a better showing this week. He wasn’t perfect by any means, but it was good to see a more positive performance. He does well to get through the linemen and blow up the screen pass. pic.twitter.com/kkvXrzpLxY
— Jonny Page (@JonnyPage9) August 18, 2025
Mondon was a terrific coverage LB in college. He could develop into a good role player and carve out a role in the nickel or dime packages. He’s a solid STer. We’ll see if he can develop into anything more than that.
***
Center Drew Kendall was the final pick of the fifth round. He had a solid showing in the preseason, but struggled to be active on gamedays. He only played in seven games, starting the season finale. I thought he looked pretty good. He snapped the ball well. His footwork was good. I thought he was pretty good with his hands, engaging defenders and trying to sustain blocks. He looked good on reach blocks. We didn’t get to see him out in space all that much.
2) I think the Eagles hit on the Drew Kendall (66) pick. He’s looked pretty good in every preseason game. Good job on the reach block here on outside zone, and you can see his initial quickness off the snap. I hope he will be a solid backup at center for a while if he continues… pic.twitter.com/pZqinxAOgP
— Jonny Page (@JonnyPage9) August 25, 2025
I think the biggest thing for me is that needs to get bigger and stronger. That will help him anchor in the pass game and get more movement in the run game.
***
OT Myles Hinton was one of several sixth round picks. He was someone that Jeff Stoutland liked a lot. We’ll have to see what the new offensive staff thinks. Hinton played over the summer and then spent the season on IR. He looked rough in the first preseason game and then was much better the next week.
#Eagles 6th round Rookie OT Myles Hinton highlights from the preseason
– Explosive first step, very agile.
– Patient with his hands, doesnt miss punches
– Elite size at 6’7, 325 with 78% wingspan and 72% arm length
– Moves well in space
– Functional Strength pic.twitter.com/hC5ggbNQes— Nick (@PhillyNick100) August 24, 2025
Hinton has great size. He shows some potential, but still struggled with the speed of the NFL game. He’ll need to take a big step forward this offseason to seriously push for a roster spot. He could be a good candidate for the practice squad.
***
Cameron Williams was another OT from the sixth round. The Eagles knew he was a project when they took him. He came out a year too early and fell in the draft. Williams has great size and length. He will show good footwork at times, but really struggles there at other times. He is sloppy with his hands and feet. He’s like a teenager that had a growth spurt and looks uncoordinated due to his new size.
In college Williams was able to win with size, length and strength. His footwork was his weakness. He started the season finale and had some good moments. He relied on his size, length and strength to win. He struggled in known passing situations due to his poor footwork, just like college. Williams does have NFL ability. He is worth trying to develop. But he’s got a long way to go. Playing in the finale probably did him a lot of good. He can study the tape. And he knows what NFL speed is like now.
***
QB Kyle McCord and edge Antwaun Powell-Ryland are no longer with the Eagles.
***
Let’s go over the UDFAs.
WR Darius Cooper came out of nowhere to have a great camp and earn a roster spot. He has good hands and is tough. He will block. He played in 13 games and finished 9-92 as a receiver. He could be a good WR4 or WR5.
Every Darius Cooper target
I really like his release package, physicality, and large catch radius. Great chance to make the 53 pic.twitter.com/ZGjAIdQdb5
— Eagles Eric (@EaglesXsandOs) August 9, 2025
Brandon Johnson played in three games, starting the finale. He can play in the slot or safety. Johnson had a good summer and showed potential. His size and length makes his best fit the slot. That’s a crowded position already so he’ll have an uphill battle for a roster spot. He could be a good fit for the practice squad as a player to develop for the future.
OL Hollin Pierce is massive. Stoutland loved guys like that. I don’t know if the new staff will value size as much. Pierce moved from OT to OG and was up and down with that. I think he’s a long shot to be back. The team has kept him around so they do like him. He moves well for a guy his size so he will have a chance to show what he can do.
I’m also going to mention Willie Lampkin, who the Eagles claimed after he was cut by the Rams. He is only 5-10, 290, but Lampkin is strong, physical and athletic. He spent the season on IR so we didn’t get to see him in green. Really interesting player who could fit at OG or C.
Brandon has a really great look at new #Eagles OL Willie Lampkin, who was claimed off waivers today from the Rams. https://t.co/uomJh4CNj4
— Devin Jackson (@RealD_Jackson) August 27, 2025
That quickness is legit. His power and leverage are impressive. Should be a very good fit for the new scheme. Can’t wait to see him play this summer.
***
For some perspective on the later picks, watch this pre-draft discussion from last April.
Howie Roseman says that he’s looking to draft starters on day three and then his staff vouches for players that they’d take a chance on in the 2025 NFL Draft.
Ty Robinson, Smael Mondon, Drew Kendall, Myles Hinton and Kyle McCord were all mentioned.
(: @Eagles) pic.twitter.com/QN0u5cGGTg
— Anthony DiBona (@DiBonaNFL) May 3, 2025
_