Let’s take a break from discussing LBs and DTs and just have an interesting discussion. Or debate. I was checking out an Eagles blog called EaglesFan4Life when I saw an interesting post there. The discussion…would the 2011 Eagles have made the playoffs with Donovan McNabb at QB?
So what do you think?
This isn’t some argument for bringing McNabb back or getting rid of Vick. This is just a hypothetical discussion. If you take away a handful of INTs last year…does that lead to an extra win and a division title? The flip side is that McNabb is a descending player who was erratic even when he was good and there might have been a clunker or two for the offense to overcome.